Matilda Sweet didn't even want to come home to Glen Haven. She's back working at the magical sweet shop she used to work at before she left Magnolia Manor to explore the big wide world. Even though she's in her thirties, she feels like she's a teenager again, under her adoptive mother Ingrid's roof, and getting up to mischief with her coven sisters. When a handsome stranger comes into the sweet shop, sparks fly, quite literally. Now she's somehow caught up in a murder mystery and the local Police officer is trying to pin it on her.